This foraged Backwoods Chokecherry Jelly recipe is easy to prepare and has the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness. If you leave it chunky, you can make Chokecherry Jam instead! And if you have more chokecherries, try my Chokecherry Syrup!
Chokecherries are currently in season. However, chokecherries are not the same thing as cherries. You won't find chokecherries at your local grocery store, so don't go looking for them there!
I've been known to pick them along windy backwoods Montana roads, with friends driving by and honking and strangers stopping to ask what I was picking and why. Yup, no shame at all, you have to get these tasty berries where you can find them!
If picked too early, the fruit has a very astringent taste that will make you "choke" or at least pucker. The berries go from green to red, to black, which is when you know that they're fair game.
I have heard it said that you should not pick chokecherries until after the first frost. However, when you're competing with other people, birds, goats, and BEARS, you gotta get'em while you can!
Jump to:
🍴Why This Recipe Works
This is a tried and tested recipe. I didn't only make this once, but four times just to get the texture and taste perfect. The precise measurements and the use of pectin will ensure that the chokecherry jelly will set every time you prepare it. Not only will you love it, but so will the recipients of your delicious gift. You are going to share, aren't you?
📝 What You Need to Make This Recipe
🥘 Recipe Ingredient Notes and Substitutions
- Chokecherries — As mentioned earlier, this wild fruit needs to be foraged and is usually ripe in August (at least in Montana). Choose the berries that are dark in color or almost black.
- Pectin — I've tried a few different types of pectin for this recipe, including liquid pectin. The one that gave me the best results was RealFruit Classic Pectin.
- Lemon Juice — I like to add a little lemon juice for the acidity. I recommend using fresh lemon juice when possible, but you can substitute bottled if you need to.
- Butter — A teaspoon of butter can cut down on the amount of foam that is produced as the chokecherry jelly boils. If you don't add the butter, you may need to skim the foam off the jelly before you can it.
- Vanilla Extract — In the past, I have used vanilla extract in my chokecherry recipes. This is mainly because I'm not a big fan of almond extract, which seems to be recommended in many recipes. Feel free to add vanilla extract, almond extract, or leave them out, like I did.
🔪 How to Make Chokecherry Jelly
Step 1 | Water Bath Canning
Wash six half-pint canning jars, then place jars in a water bath canner. Boil for 10 minutes. Keep the jars in the hot water until needed. The lids and bands can be added a few minutes before you need them.
Step 2 | Juice Chokecherries
Add cleaned chokecherries to a large saucepan. Cover with six cups of water. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat, then simmer, uncovered, over low heat, for 30 minutes. Smash the fruit to release the juice and strain the liquid through a fine strainer, jelly bag, or a few layers of cheesecloth. You should have approximately 3½ cups of chokecherry juice. If not, add enough water to equal 3½ cups.
Pro Tip: To make chokecherry jam, add some of the pulp to the juice so that you end up with a more jam-like texture.
Step 3 | Add Pectin, Lemon Juice, and Butter
Clean the saucepan and return it to the stove. Pour strained juice back into the pot. Turn the heat to medium. Whisk in RealFruit Classic Pectin until dissolved. Add lemon juice, and butter, if using. Bring the mixture to a full rolling boil, over high heat, whisking constantly.
Step 4 | Add Sugar
Next, add 4 cups of sugar, while you whisk quickly to dissolve it. Return the mixture to a full rolling boil and boil hard for one additional minute, as you continue to stir the mixture. Remove from heat and skim off the foam, if necessary. Ladle into sterilized jars, leaving ½ inch headspace. Wipe the glass jar rims with a damp kitchen towel and screw bands hand-tight.
Step 5 | Process the Chokecherry Jam/Jelly
Add jars to the canner filled with water and make sure the water level is at least a few inches over the jars. Process the filled jars in boiling water, for a minimum of 10 minutes, adding 5 additional minutes for every 1000'-3000' above sea level.
Pro Tip: Test the seals to make sure that the jars have sealed properly then store in the pantry for up to a year. If a jar has not been sealed you can either try to seal it again or store in the refrigerator to be consumed first.
💭 Recipe FAQS and Expert Tips
Chokecherries should be picked in late summer. According to nrcs.usda.gov, they are found in all but eight states here in the U.S.
In Montana, chokecherries begin ripening in August. It is generally recommended to wait until after the first frost, which is said to make the fruit sweeter and less astringent.
Chokecherries might not be the best-tasting fruit when picked off the plant, but there are many ways that the fruit can be enjoyed. Here are a few examples.
• Chokecherry Jam, Syrup, or Sauce
• Chokecherry Liqueur, Mead, or Chokecherry Wine
• Chokecherry Pie
After washing the chokecherries, add them to a large pot and cover them with an equal amount of water. Simmer the chokecherries for 30 minutes or longer. Once the fruit begins to burst, smash the berries using a potato masher. Keep in mind that if you simmer the fruit longer, more of the juice will evaporate, yielding less juice.
Strain the liquid through a sieve or jelly strainer. If you prefer a clearer liquid, don't press down on the chokecherries in an attempt to get more juice out of the berries. This can cause your juice to be cloudy.
Another great way to juice chokecherries is with a steam juicer.
The fleshy part of the choke cherry fruit is edible, while the seeds, twigs, and leaves of the plant are considered poisonous. But then again, why would you want to eat the twigs, leaves, and seeds?
- It is generally recommended to let the juice drip into a bowl, undisturbed, for a few hours instead of squeezing or pressing on the fruit. This may cause the chokecherry jam or jelly to be cloudy. This is totally up to you and how much patience you have!
- Unripe chokecherries are red and are higher in natural pectin. This means they may help your jam jell better. Having a small percentage of unripe chokecherries as part of your recipe may not be a horrible idea.
- Chokecherries can be frozen until you are ready to use them. After washing the chokecherries and removing the earwigs, spiders, and other debris, measure and portion them into freezer bags. Freeze until needed.
🍲 Related Recipes
Love this recipe? Please leave a 5-star 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟rating in the recipe card below & a review in the comments section further down the page.
Stay in touch with me through social media @ Instagram, Pinterest, TikTok, and Facebook. Don't forget to tag me when you try one of my recipes!
📖 Recipe
Backwoods Chokecherry Jelly
Ingredients
- 6 cups chokecherries
- 6 cups water
- 4½ tablespoon RealFruit Classic Pectin
- 2 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
- 1 teaspoon butter (optional)
- 4 cups sugar
Instructions
- Prepare a water bath canner, by completely covering six 8-ounce jars with water and boiling them for 10 minutes. Keep the jars in the hot water until needed. The lids can be added a few minutes before you need them.
- Add cleaned chokecherries to a six-quart Dutch oven. Cover with six cups of water. Bring to a boil and simmer, uncovered, for 30 minutes. Smash the fruit to release the juice and strain the liquid through a fine sieve. You should have approximately 3½ cups of juice. If not, add enough water to equal 3½ cups.
- Clean the Dutch oven and return to the stove. Pour strained chokecherry juice back into the pot. Turn the heat to medium. Whisk in RealFruit Classic Pectin until dissolved. Add lemon juice, and butter, if using. Bring the mixture to a full rolling boil, over high heat, whisking constantly.
- Next, add sugar, while you whisk quickly to dissolve it. Return mixture to a full rolling boil and boil hard for one additional minute, as you continue to whisk the mixture. Remove from heat and skim off the foam, if necessary. Ladle into sterilized jars, leaving ½" headspace. Wipe the glass jar rims with a damp cloth and hand-tighten the lids.
- Add jars to the canner filled with water and make sure the water level is at least a few inches over the jars. Process the filled jars in boiling water, for a minimum of 10 minutes, adding 5 additional minutes for every 1000'-3000' above sea level.
Notes
- It is generally recommended to let the juice drip into a bowl, undisturbed, for a few hours instead of squeezing or pressing on the fruit. This may cause the jelly to be cloudy. This is totally up to you and how much patience you have!
- Unripe chokecherries are red and are higher in pectin. This means they may help your jam jell better. Having a small percentage of unripe chokecherries as part of your recipe may not be a horrible idea.
- Chokecherries can be frozen until you are ready to use them. After washing the chokecherries and removing the earwigs, spiders, and other debris, measure and portion them into freezer bags. Freeze until needed.
Kelly Methey says
This is not only delicious but has a very beautiful color. Your picture should have everyone’s mouths watering! Another very interesting and delectable recipe, Hilda!
Hilda Sterner says
❤️❤️❤️
Teresa Evers says
Hilda’s Chokecherry jelly is amazing. I was lucky enough to try her new recipe. Being a local Montana resident, there are an abundance of Chokecherries around me. Her recipe is simple, it doesn’t require many ingredients. The jelly has a unique flavor, not to sweet, just right. I love it on sourdough toast with butter in the morning. This is definitely a five star rating.
Hilda Sterner says
Thank you, Teresa! So glad you're enjoying it. My favorite way to eat it is over toasted sourdough too... but with cream cheese, yum!
nancy leavitt says
Sounds perfect Hilda! Our chokecherries are almost ripe here in New Brunswick, Canada
Hilda Sterner says
Yes! It's a great crop here in Montana this year! Good luck!